← Back to Notes

The Cat Gap: Prehistoric Mysteries Behind Your Pet's Purr

Introduction: The Mystery on Your Lap

There is a good chance you are reading this with a cat nearby—perhaps curled on your lap, purring with a familiar, comforting rumble. The domestic cat is a master of the ordinary, a seemingly simple creature of naps, snacks, and inscrutable stares. We think we know them, but their history contains a mystery so vast it challenges our entire understanding of their journey to our homes.

At the heart of this mystery is a massive void in their evolutionary story, a period known as the “cat gap.” For millions of years, the fossil record in North America goes eerily silent, like a 6.5-million-year-long evolutionary crime scene with no witnesses. Unraveling this gap reveals a story of extinction, continent-spanning competition, and improbable migrations. The cat napping on your keyboard is the descendant of a survivor, and its history is far stranger than you might imagine.

1. For 6.5 Million Years, Cats Vanished from North America

The “cat gap” is a period in the North American fossil record, lasting from approximately 25 to 18.5 million years ago, where fossils of cats and cat-like species are almost entirely non-existent. For 6.5 million years, it’s as if they were simply erased from the continent.

Before this gap, North America was home to formidable predators called nimravids. Often called “false-sabertoothed cats,” these animals were a completely separate and now-extinct family of carnivores that evolved to look remarkably like cats—a stunning example of convergent evolution. Their extinction around 26 million years ago marked the beginning of the cat gap. The ecological throne for North America’s top predator was empty. The question is, who—or what—kept the cats away?

2. Cats May Have Lost an Ancient Continent-Wide War with Dogs

One of the leading theories points to a perfect storm of environmental change, fierce competition, and even massive volcanic activity. During this era, the planet was undergoing a period of global cooling. This environmental shift caused the dense forests that covered much of North America to recede, giving way to open savannas.

This was a disaster for the nimravids—a dynasty of forest specialists watching their kingdom turn to dust. As they struggled, caniforms (dog-like species, including the formidable “bear dogs”) evolved to fill the hypercarnivore niche, seemingly better suited to the new, open landscape.

However, this theory is sharply contested. Other paleontologists point out that canids never truly occupied the unique cat “morphospace”—their ecological and physical role. More puzzlingly, the fossil record shows a progressive and marked decrease in all hypercarnivorous forms during the cat gap, suggesting the problem wasn’t just that cats were outcompeted, but that the entire niche for apex predators was mysteriously shrinking.

With the continent seemingly hostile to felines and their competitors struggling to fill their shoes, the stage was set for an outside force. The next chapter in the story of the American cat would not be a local comeback, but a foreign invasion.

3. Your Cat’s Ancestors are Actually Immigrants from Asia

The felines that eventually repopulated North America were not descendants of the ancient nimravids. They were entirely new arrivals. All modern cats, from lions and tigers to the one in your living room, are descended from a genus called Pseudaelurus, the progenitor of the entire modern feline lineage.

After the 6.5-million-year gap, Pseudaelurus migrated from Asia to North America via the Bering land bridge around 18.5 million years ago. This successful journey marked the end of the cat gap and the dawn of the true cats in North America.

In essence, your cat’s ancestors are not native survivors of an ancient dynasty but the descendants of a separate, successful wave of immigrants who re-colonized a continent that had been without cats for millions of years. This new dynasty of immigrant cats would go on to conquer the continent. But their most surprising evolutionary trick wasn’t about hunting mammoths—it was about conquering human hearts and homes.

4. Cats Became Social by Remaining Eternal “Kittens”

It’s a common stereotype that cats are solitary, aloof creatures. While their direct ancestor, the African wildcat, is not particularly gregarious, domestic cats are surprisingly social and can form complex colonies. The evolutionary trick that made this possible is a phenomenon called “neoteny”—the retention of juvenile traits into adulthood.

As cats began their relationship with humans—drawn to grain stores to hunt rodents—selection pressure favored individuals who could tolerate living near people and other felines.

This idea, known as neoteny, suggests cats essentially hacked domestication by retaining their juvenile social traits. While some argue that wildcats possess the same latent social capacity, as one commenter noted, the rapid changes seen in domestication experiments with other species, like foxes, show how quickly selection pressure can favor individuals that “grow up without growing out of” the sociability of their youth. This arrested development made them more tolerant and communicative, allowing them to form the social bonds that let them coexist with us so successfully.

5. Science Fiction Has it Right: The Future May Belong to Cats and Robots

Shifting from the deep past to the speculative future, a humorous yet persistent idea emerges: no matter how advanced human technology becomes, cats will be there, being served. This theme echoes through science fiction, from stories where robots dutifully care for cats after humanity is gone, as in the game Stray or Ray Bradbury’s classic “There will come soft rains,” to the “Three Robots” episodes of Love, Death and Robots, where intelligent machines are left to ponder the last surviving cats on Earth.

This thought captures a fundamental truth about our relationship with felines: they exist alongside our world, participating in it but never truly beholden to its rules or technologies. As one observer noted, the idea of a far-future civilization powered by artificial intelligence still tending to its feline companions is a comforting one.

It’s funny to think that no matter how our technology develops, cats will be right there along for the ride, completely ignorant of it all. It’s humorously comforting to think of an interstellar civilization powered by fusion and AGI serving cats just as they’re served now. Scratching posts on starships seems to be inevitable.

Conclusion: A Deeper History

The quiet creature purring beside you is a living artifact of an epic history—a descendant of survivors from a lost world and pioneers who crossed continents. Its lineage is a testament to resilience, a story written in the gaps of the fossil record.

The cat gap is a reminder that even the most familiar parts of our world have extraordinary and mysterious stories to tell. What other secrets does our seemingly simple feline companion hold?